The acclaimed composing duo opens up about their creative process, emotional challenges, and the real human stories that shaped the score of HBO’s groundbreaking documentary.
Few documentary scores in recent memory have carried the emotional weight of The Alabama Solution, HBO’s unflinching look into the brutality, corruption, and slave-like conditions inside Alabama’s prison system. Shot largely by incarcerated men using contraband phones, the film is not only a revelation, it is a confrontation. And the sonic world behind that confrontation was crafted by composers Mark Batson and Chris Hanebutt, whose work amplifies the humanity and heartbreak embedded in every frame.
Speaking with Batson and Hanebutt reveals a creative partnership built on trust, humility, and a shared respect for storytelling. Their collaboration, spanning years across multiple projects, finds a new depth in this documentary, where music becomes both witness and vessel for truth.
Finding the Emotional Center
“When we work on film, the goal is never to overshadow the story,” Batson says. “It’s to honor it, to amplify what’s already there.” That intention became far more than philosophy when the duo first saw the raw footage from The Alabama Solution. “What we saw was alarming,” Batson recalls. “Atrocities on a level people don’t associate with the United States. Reporters aren’t allowed behind the scenes. To see it on screen was shocking.”
Hanebutt’s first reaction was visceral. “I cried,” he admits. “I knew the system was bad. But when you see what these men recorded, the beatings, the fear, the conditions, it’s worse than anything your imagination can create.”
The two composers were brought onto the project by music supervisor Sue Jacobs and worked closely with director Andrew Jarecki and producer Charlotte Kaufman, who had spent six years immersed in the story. Their mission was clear: translate a truth this heavy into music that could bear its emotional gravity without manipulation or melodrama.
“Our job isn’t to overshadow the story – it’s to amplify it.” – Mark Batson
Scoring Human Pain Without Exploitation
One of the film’s most devastating moments involves the death of Stephen Davis, whose body, brutalized beyond recognition, is presented to his grieving family. The sequence demanded sensitivity beyond technical craft.
“That scene was the most challenging,” Batson says. “The director had lived with the temp score for years, so the emotional nuances were ingrained. Creating original music that met the moment and surpassed what they were used to took immense focus.” Hanebutt estimates they scored the scene “ten to twelve times” before arriving at the version that finally resonated. “Some scenes require experimentation, others require restraint,” he says. “This one required both.”
What guided them? The people the story belongs to.
“I kept thinking about the men inside,” Batson explains. “People like Kinetic, who is essentially a hero of the film. When I spoke with him, he had this calm, peaceful demeanor, like he’d found joy in hell. That grounded me. Anytime I hit a creative wall, I thought: these men are risking their lives to tell the truth. Our challenge is nothing in comparison.”
A Creative Partnership Without Ego
The fluidity of Batson and Hanebutt’s collaboration is striking, especially in an industry known for artistic clashes. “We never step on each other’s toes,” Hanebutt says. “I’m a guitarist first. Mark’s a pianist and classically trained. We naturally divide roles. Sometimes it’s my melody, sometimes it’s his. The only goal is excellence.” Batson agrees. “We don’t bring ego into the studio. If Chris has a better idea, we use it. If I do, we use it. It’s seamless.”
Hanebutt credits Batson for helping him sharpen his own creative resilience. “Mark’s years with Dr. Dre taught him a level of patience and discipline I’ve learned from. He’s great at staying clear-headed under pressure.” And they both acknowledge the specter all creatives face.
“Imposter syndrome is real,” Hanebutt says with a laugh. “Every time the director compliments the music, I think he’s messing with me.” Batson nods. “As artists, we’re constantly questioning our work. That’s part of growth.”
“This film needs that huge cultural moment – the one where everyone says: You have to watch this.” – Chris Hanebutt
The Cultural Moment the Film Deserves
As their score makes its way into viewers’ consciousness, the composers are hopeful about the public’s willingness to confront the documentary’s harsh truths.
“People say, ‘It’s on my list,’” Hanebutt notes. “But this is heavy material. It needs that big cultural ignition point, a Joe Rogan moment, or something equally massive, to get people to watch.” The filmmakers have already held more than 65 screenings throughout Alabama in schools, churches, and community spaces. And the documentary has climbed HBO’s trending chart, rising to the No. 2 spot behind Superman.
“That was huge,” Batson says. “To see a story like this being discussed alongside mainstream blockbusters, it shows people are paying attention.” But awareness is only the beginning. “America has the highest incarceration rate in the world,” Batson continues. “Other nations have figured out how to rehabilitate people, how to prepare them to re-enter society. We haven’t. The conversations need to start there.”
Hanebutt adds, “And these men, who filmed this at great personal risk, they finally got to tell their story. That alone is powerful.”
A Story That Doesn’t End Here
For Batson and Hanebutt, scoring The Alabama Solution wasn’t just a creative assignment. It was a moral and emotional undertaking, a responsibility to the men whose lives and voices form the backbone of the film.
“I believe in redemption for everyone,” Lindsey (Talent In Borders) says in closing, sharing her own experience doing prison ministry. “The more we humanize these stories, the more impossible they become to ignore.” The duo agrees.
“This film is going to stay in people’s subconscious,” Batson says. “It’s supposed to.”
And as audiences continue to discover the documentary, the score composed by Batson and Hanebutt will echo beyond its scenes, carrying the weight of stories that demanded to be told, stories that now finally have a chance to be heard.
Get involved with The Alabama Solution here